There is No Talent Shortage: We Ran Out of Suckers

I just started the second real “motivated” job search in my 22 years. The first doesn’t really count, since it was during the depths of the 2009 recession (when everyone was out of work) and I’ve been continuously employed outside of that.

Like any other business blog reader, I’ve seen plenty of articles about the oncoming “talent shortage”. My sympathies were with HR. It truly sounded like we had a real problem.

Well, no mas! After 30 days, I’m convinced this problem is entirely created by HR.

Go sell crazy somewhere else. We’re all stocked up here.

Why Are You Reposting Jobs With Over 1000 applications?

Let’s start with my pet peeve. Employers continuously reposting positions with hundreds or thousands of responses. LinkedIn has a lovely competitive intelligence service, available to paying customers, which tells us a little bit about who else has applied. And as any good sales person knows, nothing beats a little knowledge when you’re trying to close a deal. At which point, we can take a look at this little gem:

Re-posted for at least the 4th time in as many months. We’re not talking about a CEO gig here either – once you peel back the fluff, this is a general manager role for a real estate website, with a few layers of bosses above them. In Atlanta, not New York. There are easily several thousand people in the town who are capable of doing that job. Get over yourselves and just freaking hire someone. You’re running a crappy real estate website, not curing cancer.

Somewhere along the line, the “recruiting industry” forgot their job was to get butts in seats, doing actual work.

Narrow / Irrelevant Experience Requirements

“Experience with Home Depot’s Vendor Portal required”

Posted by a national recruiting firm, no less. So let me get this straight. You’re going to toss a resume in the trash because they haven’t been keypunching data into a particular retailer’s portal? For a Sales Director Job?

Are you people complete morons?

So… I happen to know an awesome sales leader who is basically the king of big box selling. And this guy is good. He built a $40 MM business from his basement, selling “hard good” into large retailers just like Home Depot. In fact, he sold to Home Depot.

The only problem is his admin did most of the paperwork. I guess you can’t hire him.

So if you’re seriously disqualifying candidates for this, I’m beyond words.

Super Narrow Selection Criteria

So apparently you won’t be considered for a position unless you’ve worked in almost exactly that role in a company that was almost exactly the same at almost exactly the same career level.

That’s not whining, just looking at who bothers to reply back to the 100 resumes I sent.

Which is ridiculous, because certain skills are either universal or can be applied within a very broad space. I happen to know quite a bit about managing a distributor. You may safely assume that while most of my experience is in janitorial supplies, I can figure out your welding supplies business without much effort. Sell product, put on truck, ship it. Same process, same math.

Same thing with manufacturing leadership. We’ve got this massive building with huge machines and tons of people running around. Here are the detailed manuals on the equipment if we need to tweak a specific machine. Most of the rest of the job is pretty universal. Just keep reminding people to keep their fingers away from the slicey things, ok?

Aside from making it difficult to change industries or functions, there’s another huge blind-spot in this approach to assessing candidates. If you worked for a really big company, it is super easy to fake which business you were part of. Take a few people in the business to lunch, take notes, and you can rattle off more facts than a consultant. Most recruiters are utterly incapable of distinguishing this from actual experience.

Seriously. Ask me about my deep expertise in printing paper. I dare you.

Outright Age & Lifestyle Discrimination

Every good movies needs a comedy scene. I nominate the “office” interview for this role.

I’m 45 and have gray hair. That does tend to happen when you spend a few years raising teenagers and attempting to fix extremely messed up companies. It apparently indicates I am completely ignorant about technology and social media.

Never mind that billion dollar public companies have used code I’ve written in the past three years to make legally binding statements. As in “go to jail if you get this wrong” stuff. Silly executives. They shouldn’t have used an old guy to write that code.

But the real prizewinner comes when we speak about my current remote working arrangement. “Are you willing to commute into the office after working remotely?”

What kind of question is that? The job is an office job and I applied. Why is this an issue?

What Are Your Salary Requirements?

So let me get this straight. You want me to bootstrap a multi-million dollar business, from scratch, operating with minimal marketing and operating funding in a highly competitive channel. Or get your consumer product slotted at a major retailer. Or launch your new web application. For a basic salary and lousy incentives.

No, seriously – what are you smoking? Because I want some of it.

Let’s be clear – all of those tasks are achievable. And will generate millions of dollars in equity for your company. And I’m pretty sure you’re going to fire me within a year or two if this doesn’t work out, so this isn’t a low risk deal.

What you’re missing is that while you may need someone like me to get this done, people like me don’t really need you anymore. We can outsource or import product. We can hire freelancers. Financing is out there. We may not want to assume the risk of startup business right now but if you’re going to offer the deal on those terms…

Basically you want us create millions of dollars in value, get paid a pittance for our troubles, and get stuck holding the bag if things don’t work out. You’re not recruiting geniuses, you’re recruiting suckers.

Stop wasting people’s time and make experienced candidates a real offer.

No Kidding People Don’t Get Hired

I mean seriously, it’s probably faster to just try to go sell your company something than actually get a job there. Probably more profitable too, while we’re talking about it.

To heck with Human Resources. Anyone got the number for purchasing?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *